Home - Appeals, Motions and Waivers - RFE Response Lawyer: Requests for Evidence and Notices of Intent to Deny
RFE Response Lawyer: Requests for Evidence and Notices of Intent to Deny
A Request for Evidence (RFE) means USCIS has reviewed a petition or application and decided the record does not yet establish eligibility. In most cases the response is the last thing the officer reads before deciding. Immigration Law Group prepares RFE and Notice of Intent to Deny responses for employers and individuals, including in cases first filed by other counsel.
The rules that govern an RFE
- One deadline, no extensions. The notice states the due date. USCIS may allow at most twelve weeks for an RFE and thirty days for a Notice of Intent to Deny, and additional time may not be granted (8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv)).
- One response. All requested materials must be submitted together at one time. A partial response is treated as a request for a decision on the record as it stands (8 CFR 103.2(b)(11)).
- No response means denial. If the deadline passes, USCIS can deny the case as abandoned, deny it on the record, or both (8 CFR 103.2(b)(13)).
- Eligibility at filing. The response has to show the case was approvable on the day it was filed. Evidence of facts that arose later does not cure a case that was not eligible at filing (8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) and (b)(12)).
- Evidence, not assertion. The standard is a preponderance of the evidence (Matter of Chawathe, 25 I&N Dec. 369 (AAO 2010)). Unsupported statements do not meet it (Matter of Soffici, 22 I&N Dec. 158 (Comm’r 1998)), and statements by counsel are not evidence (Matter of Obaigbena, 19 I&N Dec. 533 (BIA 1988)).
How we prepare a response
- Read the RFE against the law. We compare each request with the statute, the regulation and USCIS policy for the classification. Where the notice asks for more than the law requires or applies the wrong standard, the response says so and cites the authority.
- Find what the officer doubts. Behind a long list of requested documents there are usually one or two real questions. The response is organized around those.
- Answer with documents. Each point gets primary evidence where it exists: contracts, organizational charts, payroll and tax records, corporate filings, publications, and independent letters that state the writer’s basis of knowledge.
- File one complete, indexed submission on time. The cover brief states the standard, walks through the evidence exhibit by exhibit, and addresses every item in the notice.
Common RFE issues by case type
- H-1B: whether the position is a specialty occupation, whether the degree fits the position, third-party worksites, wage level, and maintenance of status. See H-1B visa lawyer.
- L-1: the qualifying corporate relationship, managerial or executive capacity, specialized knowledge, the one year of employment abroad, and new office requirements. See L-1 visa lawyer.
- EB-1 and O-1: whether the evidence meets the regulatory criteria and, for EB-1, the final merits determination. See EB-1 visa lawyer and O-1 visa lawyer.
- EB-2 National Interest Waiver: the three prongs of Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016). See EB-2 NIW lawyer.
- I-140 petitions: the employer’s ability to pay the offered wage and proof that the worker met the labor certification requirements. See PERM labor certification.
- E-2: whether the investment is substantial and at risk, whether the enterprise is more than marginal, and the applicant’s role. See E-2 visa lawyer.
Notices of Intent to Deny and to Revoke
A Notice of Intent to Deny allows no more than thirty days. A Notice of Intent to Revoke an approved petition must give the petitioner an opportunity to offer evidence against the grounds alleged (8 CFR 205.2(b)), by the deadline stated in the notice. Both call for the same approach on a shorter clock.
If the case is denied
A denial can be challenged by a motion to reopen or reconsider, by an appeal, or answered with a new filing. The deadline for a motion or an appeal is generally 30 days from the decision, so the choice has to be made quickly.
Client Reviews
What an amazing team to work with. SO grateful for Jen, Catherine and the whole team, who worked so hard and were so patient with us through this whole process of obtaining our green cards. They are truly experts and can be trusted without a doubt to help you with your immigration needs! Utmost professionals and a pleasure to work with.
Sarah C.
Immigration Law Group has a wonderful team of lawyers. They handled my h1b and permanent residence paperwork in a way that really made me feel comfortable and brought me peace through a very stressful time. they are on top of things and always answered my questions in a timely manner. I highly recommend them if you want to make sure everything goes perfectly.
Kiran M.
Everyone at Immigration Law Group, from the attorneys to support staff, have been nothing but helpful, well-informed, and courteous to me from the start until now. Jen, and Catherine in particular, have been super helpful in explaining complicated procedures and processes in easy to understand ways–yet not dumbing down to the level where they are leaving out important details. I feel confident and knowledgeable with ILG working on my case, and there’s a personal level of communication and trust, which also puts me at ease during a difficult and tricky process. I highly recommend Immigration Law Group–I’m so glad I found them!
Andrew O.
We are very satisfied with the Immigration Law Group and the services they had provided us so far. They have very capable staff that is always on top of our cases and help us navigate them successfully. We have had great success with all cases and their rates are very reasonable. They know Immigration law better than any other law firm we worked with. I would recommend them without hesitation!
Alina T.
Common questions
Can USCIS extend the RFE deadline?
No. The regulation bars additional time (8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv)). A late response leads to denial.
Does an RFE mean the case will be denied?
No. It means the officer is not yet satisfied. Cases are regularly approved after a complete response. A weak or partial response usually ends the case.
Can you respond to an RFE on a case another attorney filed?
Yes. We enter our appearance on Form G-28 and respond on the existing record. We need the full filing, the RFE and any earlier correspondence as soon as possible, because the deadline does not move.
Should we respond or refile?
If the petition was eligible when filed and the gap is one of proof, respond. If the facts that would fix the case arose after filing, a new petition is often the better route, sometimes alongside a response.
Speak with an immigration attorney
Immigration Law Group has practiced exclusively in immigration law for over 30 years.