Home - Employment Visas - PERM Labor Certification Lawyer
PERM Labor Certification Lawyer
PERM is the Department of Labor process an employer must complete before sponsoring most workers for an EB-2 or EB-3 green card. The employer tests the U.S. labor market for the position and certifies that no able, willing, qualified and available U.S. worker was found, and that hiring the foreign worker will not adversely affect the wages and working conditions of U.S. workers (INA 212(a)(5)(A)). Immigration Law Group has practiced employment-based immigration law since 1996.
When a labor certification is required
Most EB-2 petitions and EB-3 petitions need a certified PERM application before the employer can file Form I-140. No labor certification is needed for EB-1 petitions, for EB-2 National Interest Waiver petitions, or for the Schedule A occupations the Department of Labor has pre-certified (20 CFR 656.5).
The PERM process
- Define the job and its minimum requirements. The requirements stated on the application must be the employer’s actual minimum requirements (20 CFR 656.17(i)(1)) and must be those normally required for the occupation unless the employer can document business necessity (20 CFR 656.17(h)(1)). The application cannot be modified after filing (20 CFR 656.11(b)), so errors at this step cannot be repaired later.
- Obtain a prevailing wage determination. The National Prevailing Wage Center sets the minimum wage the employer must offer. The determination is valid for a stated period of at least 90 days and at most one year, and the employer must begin recruitment or file within that period (20 CFR 656.40(c)).
- Recruit. For professional positions the employer places a job order with the State Workforce Agency for 30 days, runs advertisements on two different Sundays in a newspaper of general circulation, and completes three additional recruitment steps from the list in the regulation (20 CFR 656.17(e)(1)). A notice of filing must be posted at the worksite for at least 10 consecutive business days (20 CFR 656.10(d)). Each step has to fall inside fixed windows of 30 and 180 days before filing.
- Review applicants. The employer must consider every U.S. applicant and may reject one only for lawful, job-related reasons, which are recorded in a signed recruitment report (20 CFR 656.17(g)).
- File Form ETA-9089. The application is filed electronically with the Department of Labor. The date it is accepted for processing becomes the priority date of the green card case (8 CFR 204.5(d)).
- Respond to any audit. The Certifying Officer can audit an application for cause or at random. The employer has 30 days to submit the documentation requested, with one extension of up to 30 days at the officer’s discretion. An employer that does not respond in time is denied and loses access to administrative review (20 CFR 656.20).
- File the I-140. A certified application expires unless it is filed with a Form I-140 within 180 calendar days of certification (20 CFR 656.30(b)(1)).
Where PERM applications fail
- Requirements the worker did not meet at hire. An employer generally cannot require experience that the sponsored worker gained on the job with the same employer, unless the earlier position was not substantially comparable or it is no longer feasible to train a new worker (20 CFR 656.17(i)(3)). For this rule the employer is the entity with the same Federal Employer Identification Number (20 CFR 656.17(i)(5)), so the worker’s employment history, entity by entity, has to be checked before the requirements are set.
- Advertisements that do not match the application. The advertisements, the job order, the notice of filing and Form ETA-9089 must describe the same job, the same requirements and the same worksite.
- Timing errors. A recruitment step outside the 30 and 180 day windows, an expired prevailing wage determination, or a notice of filing posted for too few business days is each a ground for denial.
- Layoffs. If the employer laid off U.S. workers in the same or a related occupation in the area of intended employment within six months of filing, it must notify and consider those workers (20 CFR 656.17(k)).
- Thin documentation. An audit asks for proof of every step. An employer that cannot produce the advertisements, postings, resumes and the reasons each applicant was rejected faces denial.
If the Department of Labor denies the application
The employer has 30 days from the denial to ask the Certifying Officer to reconsider (20 CFR 656.24(g)) or to request review by the Board of Alien Labor Certification Appeals (20 CFR 656.26). Reconsideration is limited to documentation the employer already submitted, or that existed when the application was filed and could not be presented earlier. A new application for the same worker and occupation cannot be filed while a request for Board review is pending (20 CFR 656.24(e)(6)), so the choice between contesting the denial and refiling has to be made deliberately. It turns on the denial ground and on how much the priority date is worth. See our page on immigration appeals.
PERM and the H-1B six-year limit
Timing matters most for workers approaching the six-year limit on H-1B status. Once 365 days have passed since a labor certification or I-140 was filed for the worker, H-1B status can be extended beyond six years, and a worker with an approved I-140 who is held back only by the per-country limits can also be extended (8 CFR 214.2(h)(13)(iii)(D) and (E)). An employer that waits too long to start PERM can lose the worker before the green card case catches up.
How we handle PERM cases
- We settle the job description, the minimum requirements and the worker’s qualifying experience with the employer before recruitment starts.
- We run the recruitment calendar against the regulatory windows and the prevailing wage validity period.
- We build the audit file as the case proceeds, so a response is ready if an audit letter arrives.
- We prepare the I-140 during the PERM stage so it can be filed as soon as the application is certified.
Related guides
- EB-2 visa lawyer
- EB-3 visa lawyer
- Beyond the Label: Maintaining Rights and Status as a Permanent Resident Alien
- EB1 vs EB2 vs EB3: Choose Wisely and Maximize Your Chances
- EB2 vs EB3 Visa: Understanding the Differences
- Employment Based Green Card Process Walkthrough
- Employment Based Green Card Timeline: What to Expect and When
- Employment Green Card Interview Guide: Be Ready for Success
- From Specialized Knowledge to Permanent Status: The Transition Strategy for L-1B Staff
- Know the 5 Employment-Based Green Card Categories
- L1 Visa to Green Card: Complete Guide
- L1B Visa to Green Card: Making the Transition
- Steps How To Transfer From TN Visa To Green Card
Client Reviews
What an amazing team to work with. SO grateful for Jen, Catherine and the whole team, who worked so hard and were so patient with us through this whole process of obtaining our green cards. They are truly experts and can be trusted without a doubt to help you with your immigration needs! Utmost professionals and a pleasure to work with.
Sarah C.
Immigration Law Group has a wonderful team of lawyers. They handled my h1b and permanent residence paperwork in a way that really made me feel comfortable and brought me peace through a very stressful time. they are on top of things and always answered my questions in a timely manner. I highly recommend them if you want to make sure everything goes perfectly.
Kiran M.
Everyone at Immigration Law Group, from the attorneys to support staff, have been nothing but helpful, well-informed, and courteous to me from the start until now. Jen, and Catherine in particular, have been super helpful in explaining complicated procedures and processes in easy to understand ways–yet not dumbing down to the level where they are leaving out important details. I feel confident and knowledgeable with ILG working on my case, and there’s a personal level of communication and trust, which also puts me at ease during a difficult and tricky process. I highly recommend Immigration Law Group–I’m so glad I found them!
Andrew O.
We are very satisfied with the Immigration Law Group and the services they had provided us so far. They have very capable staff that is always on top of our cases and help us navigate them successfully. We have had great success with all cases and their rates are very reasonable. They know Immigration law better than any other law firm we worked with. I would recommend them without hesitation!
Alina T.
Common questions
Who pays for PERM?
The employer. The regulations bar an employer from seeking or receiving payment of any kind for activity related to obtaining the labor certification, including its attorneys’ fees and the costs of preparing and filing the application (20 CFR 656.12(b)).
Does the worker have to be employed by the sponsor already?
No. PERM is for a permanent, full-time position the employer intends to fill when the green card is approved. The worker may be abroad, working for the sponsor in a temporary status, or working elsewhere.
What if the job or the worksite changes after filing?
Form ETA-9089 cannot be amended after it is filed. A material change in the job, its requirements or the area of intended employment usually means a new application.
Which green card categories use PERM?
EB-2 for positions requiring an advanced degree, and EB-3 for skilled workers, professionals and other workers. Our comparison of EB-2 and EB-3 explains how the category is chosen, and our employment-based green card page covers the full sequence.
Speak with an immigration attorney
Immigration Law Group has practiced exclusively in immigration law for over 30 years.