Motion to Reopen and Motion to Reconsider Lawyer

After USCIS denies a petition or application, a motion asks the office that made the decision to change it. A motion to reopen puts new facts before the agency. A motion to reconsider argues that the decision misapplied the law or USCIS policy to the record as it stood. Both are filed on Form I-290B. Immigration Law Group prepares both for employers and individuals.

Deadlines

  • A motion must be filed within 30 days of the decision (8 CFR 103.5(a)(1)(i)). When the decision was served by mail, three days are added (8 CFR 103.8(b)).
  • A late motion to reopen can be accepted in USCIS’s discretion if the delay was reasonable and beyond the filer’s control. The regulation gives no such exception for a motion to reconsider.
  • Filing a motion does not stay the decision or extend a departure date (8 CFR 103.5(a)(1)(iv)). Status, work authorization and unlawful presence have to be analyzed separately, and immediately.

Motion to reopen

A motion to reopen must state the new facts to be proved and support them with affidavits or other documentary evidence (8 CFR 103.5(a)(2)). It fits a case where evidence that would have changed the result existed but was not in the record: a document that could not be obtained in time, a response USCIS did not match to the file, or a fact the officer got wrong that can now be proved.

Where a case was denied as abandoned for failure to answer a Request for Evidence, the motion must show that the requested evidence was not material, that the response was in fact submitted on time, or that USCIS sent the request to an address other than the one on file or failed to use a new address it had been given in writing (8 CFR 103.5(a)(2)(i)-(iii)).

Motion to reconsider

A motion to reconsider must state the reasons for reconsideration, cite pertinent precedent decisions showing that the decision rested on an incorrect application of law or USCIS policy, and establish that the decision was incorrect on the evidence of record at the time (8 CFR 103.5(a)(3)). No new evidence is involved. It fits a denial that applied the wrong legal standard, overlooked evidence that was in the file, or demanded something the regulation does not require.

The two can be combined in one filing when a denial has both problems.

Motion, appeal or new petition

  • Motion: decided by the office that issued the denial (8 CFR 103.5(a)(1)(ii)). It is the administrative remedy where no appeal exists, as with most denials of adjustment of status (8 CFR 245.2(a)(5)(ii)), and it suits an error the deciding office can see and correct itself.
  • Appeal: goes to the Administrative Appeals Office for most employment-based petitions. The office that denied the case reviews the appeal first and can treat it as a motion and approve it (8 CFR 103.3(a)(2)(iii)). See immigration appeals.
  • New petition: the right vehicle when the facts that cure the problem arose after the original filing, because eligibility must exist at the time of filing (8 CFR 103.2(b)(1)). A new filing can proceed alongside a motion.

Who can file

Only the affected party can file a motion. For a visa petition that is the petitioner, usually the employer or the family member who filed. The beneficiary of a visa petition is not an affected party (8 CFR 103.3(a)(1)(iii)(B)).

How we handle motions

  1. We calculate the deadline from the decision date at the first contact.
  2. We obtain the complete record: the original filing, any RFE and response, and the decision.
  3. We decide within days whether the case calls for a motion to reopen, a motion to reconsider, both, an appeal, a new petition, or a combination.
  4. We write the brief to the grounds the decision states, tie each point to the record or to new evidence, and file a complete package before the deadline.

For family cases, see our guide to filing a motion to reopen based on an approved I-130. If the case is still at the RFE stage, see RFE responses.

Client Reviews

What an amazing team to work with. SO grateful for Jen, Catherine and the whole team, who worked so hard and were so patient with us through this whole process of obtaining our green cards. They are truly experts and can be trusted without a doubt to help you with your immigration needs! Utmost professionals and a pleasure to work with.

Sarah C.

Immigration Law Group has a wonderful team of lawyers. They handled my h1b and permanent residence paperwork in a way that really made me feel comfortable and brought me peace through a very stressful time. they are on top of things and always answered my questions in a timely manner. I highly recommend them if you want to make sure everything goes perfectly.

Kiran M.

Everyone at Immigration Law Group, from the attorneys to support staff, have been nothing but helpful, well-informed, and courteous to me from the start until now. Jen, and Catherine in particular, have been super helpful in explaining complicated procedures and processes in easy to understand ways–yet not dumbing down to the level where they are leaving out important details. I feel confident and knowledgeable with ILG working on my case, and there’s a personal level of communication and trust, which also puts me at ease during a difficult and tricky process. I highly recommend Immigration Law Group–I’m so glad I found them!

Andrew O.

We are very satisfied with the Immigration Law Group and the services they had provided us so far. They have very capable staff that is always on top of our cases and help us navigate them successfully. We have had great success with all cases and their rates are very reasonable. They know Immigration law better than any other law firm we worked with. I would recommend them without hesitation!

Alina T.

Common questions

A motion to reopen rests on new facts supported by new evidence. A motion to reconsider rests on legal error in the decision, judged on the record as it existed.

Thirty days from the date of the decision, or 33 days if the decision was mailed. Only a motion to reopen can be accepted late, and only where the delay was reasonable and beyond the filer’s control.

Generally no. The employer is the affected party and must file. The worker’s cooperation and documents are usually still needed.

A motion does not restore or extend status and does not stop the denial from taking effect. Anyone whose status depends on the denied case needs advice on that question before the motion is filed.

Sometimes that is the better course, especially when the first filing was thin or the facts have changed. A new petition does not erase the earlier denial, and the new filing has to address it.

Speak with an immigration attorney

Immigration Law Group has practiced exclusively in immigration law for over 30 years.