Home - Appeals, Motions and Waivers - Immigration Appeals Lawyer: USCIS, AAO and BALCA
Immigration Appeals Lawyer: USCIS, AAO and BALCA
Which body reviews an immigration denial depends on the kind of case and on who issued the decision. Immigration Law Group handles motions to reopen and reconsider before USCIS, appeals to the USCIS Administrative Appeals Office, and requests for review before the Board of Alien Labor Certification Appeals.
Appeals to the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO)
- What it covers: most employment-based petition denials, including H-1B, L-1 and O-1 petitions on Form I-129 and immigrant petitions on Form I-140, along with many waiver applications.
- Deadline: the appeal is filed on Form I-290B within 30 days after service of the decision, or 33 days if the decision was mailed, with the supporting brief filed as the form instructions direct (8 CFR 103.3(a)(2)(i); 8 CFR 103.8(b)). An appeal from the revocation of an approved petition must be filed within 15 days after service of the notice (8 CFR 205.2(d)).
- First review by the deciding office: the office that denied the case reviews the appeal and, within 45 days, may treat it as a motion and take favorable action. Otherwise it forwards the appeal and the record to the AAO (8 CFR 103.3(a)(2)(iii)-(iv)).
- Specificity: an appeal that does not identify an erroneous conclusion of law or statement of fact is summarily dismissed (8 CFR 103.3(a)(1)(v)).
- The record: evidence that USCIS requested in an RFE and did not receive will generally not be considered for the first time on appeal (Matter of Soriano, 19 I&N Dec. 764 (BIA 1988)).
Denials of family-based petitions on Form I-130 follow a different path, to the Board of Immigration Appeals.
PERM denials: reconsideration and BALCA
When the Department of Labor denies a labor certification, the employer has 30 days to request reconsideration by the Certifying Officer (20 CFR 656.24(g)) or review by the Board of Alien Labor Certification Appeals (20 CFR 656.26). The record on review is narrow. With limited exceptions it is confined to what the employer submitted before the denial. An employer that fails to answer an audit letter on time loses access to review altogether (20 CFR 656.20(a)(3)). See PERM labor certification.
Choosing the remedy
An appeal is one of several tools. A motion to reopen or reconsider returns the case to the office that decided it. A new petition may be the better course where the record can be improved. We weigh these options against the client’s timeline, the worker’s status and the strength of the record before recommending one.
Client Reviews
What an amazing team to work with. SO grateful for Jen, Catherine and the whole team, who worked so hard and were so patient with us through this whole process of obtaining our green cards. They are truly experts and can be trusted without a doubt to help you with your immigration needs! Utmost professionals and a pleasure to work with.
Sarah C.
Immigration Law Group has a wonderful team of lawyers. They handled my h1b and permanent residence paperwork in a way that really made me feel comfortable and brought me peace through a very stressful time. they are on top of things and always answered my questions in a timely manner. I highly recommend them if you want to make sure everything goes perfectly.
Kiran M.
Everyone at Immigration Law Group, from the attorneys to support staff, have been nothing but helpful, well-informed, and courteous to me from the start until now. Jen, and Catherine in particular, have been super helpful in explaining complicated procedures and processes in easy to understand ways–yet not dumbing down to the level where they are leaving out important details. I feel confident and knowledgeable with ILG working on my case, and there’s a personal level of communication and trust, which also puts me at ease during a difficult and tricky process. I highly recommend Immigration Law Group–I’m so glad I found them!
Andrew O.
We are very satisfied with the Immigration Law Group and the services they had provided us so far. They have very capable staff that is always on top of our cases and help us navigate them successfully. We have had great success with all cases and their rates are very reasonable. They know Immigration law better than any other law firm we worked with. I would recommend them without hesitation!
Alina T.
Common questions
Does filing an appeal let the worker stay or keep working?
No. An appeal does not confer status or work authorization and does not stop a denial from taking effect. Those questions need separate answers before the appeal is filed.
Can new evidence be submitted on appeal?
In most AAO appeals, yes, with the brief. The exception is evidence USCIS asked for in an RFE that was not provided when requested.
Can we appeal and file a new petition at the same time?
For USCIS petitions, generally yes. PERM is different: a new application for the same worker and occupation cannot be filed while a request for Board review is pending (20 CFR 656.24(e)(6)).
Is a motion or an appeal the better choice?
It depends on the error. New facts and plain mistakes by the deciding office usually call for a motion. A disputed legal standard usually calls for an appeal or a suit. See our page on motions to reopen and reconsider.
Speak with an immigration attorney
Immigration Law Group has practiced exclusively in immigration law for over 30 years.