The L-1 moves an employee from a company abroad into a related company in the United States. That is the whole idea, and everything below follows from it.
Most writing about the L-1 is aimed at the employee. The harder question is usually the company one. An employee can be perfectly qualified and the petition still fails, because the two companies do not have the relationship the law requires, or because one of them cannot show it is genuinely trading. We see more L-1 cases die on the corporate side than on anything the employee did or did not do.
This page starts from the beginning and then goes into the difficult parts. If you already know the basics, skip to where corporate structures fail.
Two words you will see throughout
The company that sponsors is the petitioner. The employee being transferred is the beneficiary. Government forms and decisions use those words, and so does the rest of this page.
One more. When the government wants more proof before deciding, it issues a request for evidence, usually shortened to RFE. It is not a denial. It is a demand to prove something the petition asserted but did not establish, and most L-1 corporate problems surface there.
What has to be true
Four things, in plain terms:
- The two companies are related to each other in one of four specific ways.
- Both companies are actually operating, not just registered.
- The employee worked for the company abroad for a full year out of the last three.
- That work, and the job here, is managerial, executive, or involves specialized knowledge.
Each of those is narrower than it sounds. The rest of this page is what each one actually means.
Does your organization qualify
The petitioner must be what the regulation calls a qualifying organization. 8 CFR 214.2(l)(1)(ii)(G) defines that as an entity which meets exactly one of the qualifying relationships specified in the definitions of a parent, branch, affiliate or subsidiary
and which is or will be doing business (engaging in international trade is not required) as an employer in the United States and in at least one other country
for the duration of the stay.
Two requirements, both corporate. Ownership and control on one side, active operations on both sides on the other.
Note the phrase exactly one
. The relationship has to be identifiable as a specific category, not asserted generally. A petition that says the companies are “related” or “part of the same group” has not answered the question.
The four relationships, and where each one breaks
The regulation defines them at 8 CFR 214.2(l)(1)(ii)(I) through (L). In plain terms: one company owns the other, or they are two arms of the same company, or they are both owned by the same people.
Parent. A firm, corporation, or other legal entity which has subsidiaries.
Straightforward, and it depends entirely on the subsidiary definition below.
Branch. An operating division or office of the same organization housed in a different location.
One legal entity, two places. No ownership question arises because there is nothing to own. What does arise is whether the branch is an operating division or just a registered address, which is a doing business problem.
Subsidiary. The definition is longer than people expect, and the detail matters:
A firm, corporation, or other legal entity of which a parent owns, directly or indirectly, more than half of the entity and controls the entity; or owns, directly or indirectly, half of the entity and controls the entity; or owns, directly or indirectly, 50 percent of a 50-50 joint venture and has equal control and veto power over the entity; or owns, directly or indirectly, less than half of the entity, but in fact controls the entity.
Two things follow from that. Ownership below 50% can still qualify where the parent in fact controls
the entity, which is a question of proof rather than arithmetic. And a 50-50 joint venture qualifies only with equal control and veto power. A 50-50 split with no veto right written into the operating agreement is not a subsidiary. That is a drafting problem rather than an immigration one, and it is worth reading the agreement before filing rather than after the RFE.
Affiliate. (1) One of two subsidiaries both of which are owned and controlled by the same parent or individual, or (2) One of two legal entities owned and controlled by the same group of individuals, each individual owning and controlling approximately the same share or proportion of each entity
.
The second branch catches closely held companies. Where the same four founders own both companies but in different proportions, they are not affiliates. Approximately the same share or proportion
is the test, and ownership that drifted apart across two funding rounds will fail it.
Where corporate structures actually fail
These are the recurring ones.
A contract is not a relationship. Franchise agreements, licensing deals, distribution agreements, master services agreements and exclusive agency arrangements create obligations, not ownership. None of them makes two companies a parent, branch, subsidiary or affiliate. This is the most common structural defect we see, and it is usually fatal rather than fixable.
The foreign side is a holding company. Ownership is clean, but the entity abroad holds shares and does nothing else. Doing business
is defined at 8 CFR 214.2(l)(1)(ii)(H) as the regular, systematic, and continuous provision of goods and/or services by a qualifying organization
and expressly does not include the mere presence of an agent or office of the qualifying organization in the United States and abroad
. A pure holding company provides no goods or services. The requirement can sometimes be met through a parent, branch, affiliate or subsidiary in that country, which is why the structure needs mapping before anything is filed.
Control is real but undocumented. The group knows who controls what. The file contains no stock certificates, no cap table, no share register, no board resolutions and no purchase agreements. Control asserted in a support letter and nowhere else does not survive an RFE. Build the ownership chain from the documents that created it.
The ownership chain runs through several countries. Indirect ownership qualifies, but every link has to be evidenced. A chain through three holding entities in three jurisdictions needs all three documented, and the link nobody can produce is usually the dormant intermediate company.
The foreign parent has wound down. The United States business grew, the original operation abroad quietly stopped trading, and nobody noticed until the extension. The L-1 requires both sides to be doing business for the whole of the employee’s stay. This defect surfaces at renewal rather than at the first filing, when the employee is already here.
The group restructured mid-case. A merger, a share sale or an internal reorganization between approval and extension can mean the relationship that was approved no longer exists. Where a new entity has assumed the rights and obligations of the original petitioner there is a successor in interest argument to make, but it has to be made and documented rather than assumed.
The entity was created for the transfer. A company incorporated to support an immigration filing, with no capital, no premises and no trade, is a new office case at best. See below.
Doing business means operating
Regular, systematic and continuous provision of goods or services. An entity that exists on paper, holds an address, or has an agent but no operations does not satisfy this. Tax filings, payroll records, contracts, invoices, bank statements and financial statements carry it. A website and a letterhead do not.
Then the employee requirements
One continuous year of employment with a qualifying entity abroad within the three years before the transfer, in a managerial, executive or specialized knowledge capacity, and a role here in one of those capacities. Proved by what the person actually did, not by their title. See what an L-1 petition must prove.
Two points inside that are worth knowing before you choose which category to file.
Managers do not need direct reports. 8 CFR 214.2(l)(1)(ii)(B) includes an employee who manages an essential function within the organization, or a department or subdivision of the organization
, and provides that where no other employee is directly supervised
the employee must function at a senior level within the organizational hierarchy or with respect to the function managed
. That is the functional manager, and it is the right category for a senior person who owns a function rather than a team. It is also adjudicated skeptically, so the function, its importance to the organization and the employee’s seniority over it all have to be shown rather than stated.
Specialized knowledge has two prongs. 8 CFR 214.2(l)(1)(ii)(D) covers special knowledge possessed by an individual of the petitioning organization’s product, service, research, equipment, techniques, management, or other interests and its application in international markets
, or an advanced level of knowledge or expertise in the organization’s processes and procedures
. Those are two different arguments and they need different evidence. Knowledge that any competent person in the industry would have is neither.
The choice between L-1A and L-1B is not cosmetic. L-1B is capped at five years and L-1A at seven under 8 CFR 214.2(l)(12). The EB-1C green card is a separate filing with its own test. It does not require L-1A status, or L status at all. It asks whether the year abroad and the job here are both managerial or executive, and 8 CFR 204.5(j)(5) provides that No labor certification is required for this classification
. A role that qualifies for L-1A will usually meet it. The catch for an L-1B employee is the year abroad: an L-1 can rest on a year of specialized knowledge work abroad, and EB-1C cannot. Filing L-1B because it looks like the easier approval gives up two years of time, and where the job is in truth managerial it leaves the later green card petition explaining why it was first described as something else.
If you are opening the United States entity now
A company with no United States operation yet can still transfer someone in to start one. This is a new office petition, and for a manager or executive it has its own evidence rules at 8 CFR 214.2(l)(3)(v). The petitioner must show that sufficient physical premises to house the new office have been secured
, that the employee was employed abroad for one continuous year in the preceding three in an executive or managerial capacity, and that the United States operation within one year of the approval of the petition, will support an executive or managerial position
.
The premises requirement means secured, not identified. A signed lease, not a letter of intent and not a co-working membership bought the week before filing.
The third element is the one that ends these cases. A new office approval runs one year, and the extension asks whether the business actually grew into something that supports a manager or an executive. A company that spent that year with the employee doing the work rather than managing it will not have the staffing, the revenue or the organizational chart to carry the extension. Plan the first year against that test from the day the petition is approved, not in month eleven.
Talk to us
If you are not certain which of the four relationships your group has, or whether the entity abroad is still doing business in the regulatory sense, that is the question to settle before anything is filed. We have practiced U.S. immigration law exclusively for over 30 years. Call the firm and we will tell you plainly whether the structure supports an L-1 and what it would take to fix it if it does not.