A no match letter says the name and Social Security number reported for an employee do not agree with the agency records. It does not say the employee lacks work authorization, and treating it as though it does is how employers turn an administrative discrepancy into a lawsuit.
What causes a mismatch
Typographical errors in payroll. Name changes after marriage or divorce that were never reported to SSA. Compound or hyphenated surnames recorded differently by different systems. Transposed digits. Records that were never updated after a change of status. Most no match letters involve United States citizens.
What you must not do
This is the part that matters legally.
Do not terminate, suspend or take adverse action based on the letter alone. A no match is not evidence of unauthorised status, and acting as if it were is exactly the conduct 8 U.S.C. 1324b reaches.
Do not demand specific documents. Asking for more or different documents than are required
is an unfair documentary practice in its own right. You are not re-running employment eligibility verification.
Do not apply it selectively. Whatever process you adopt has to be the same for every employee named, regardless of how their name sounds or where you believe they are from.
Do not ignore it entirely either. Repeated notices that are never addressed can later be argued as constructive knowledge. The answer is a consistent, documented, neutral process.
What a reasonable process looks like
Check your own records first, because payroll error is the single most common cause. If your records match what you reported, tell the employee in private, give them a reasonable period to address it with SSA, and document that you did so. Apply the same steps and the same timeline to everyone. Keep the file.
If this is ever examined, the question will be whether you had a consistent process and followed it. The answer will be whatever your documentation shows.
The underlying tension
Employers are caught between two bodies of law: one that penalises employing unauthorised workers, and one that penalises treating workers differently because of how their paperwork looks. A no match letter sits precisely on that line, which is why the instinct to act decisively is usually the wrong one.
Talk to us
If you have received no match letters and have no written process, that is worth fixing before the next batch arrives. We have practiced U.S. immigration law exclusively for over 30 years. Call the firm and we will tell you plainly whether you have a case and what it will take.
Further reading: the anti-discrimination rule, E-Verify exposure.