A mismatch is the moment E-Verify stops being an administrative convenience and becomes a compliance exposure. The rules are specific, the clocks are short, and the most expensive mistakes are the ones employers make out of good intentions.
What a mismatch is
A tentative nonconfirmation, now called a mismatch, means the information entered did not match records held by DHS or the Social Security Administration. It is not a finding that the employee lacks work authorization. Common causes are entirely innocent: a name change after marriage, a hyphenated or compound surname entered differently, a data entry error, or records not yet updated after a status change.
The employer obligations, in order
Act within 10 federal government working days after receipt. That is the window E-Verify gives the employer to take the required steps.
Inform the employee in private. E-Verify states this expressly. Not in front of colleagues, not by group email, not through a supervisor who does not need to know.
Allow the employee the option to take action to resolve it. The choice belongs to the employee, not to you.
If the employee contests, the employee then has 8 federal government working days from the Referral Date Confirmation date to take action with DHS or SSA.
The rule that generates the lawsuits
In E-Verify own words: You may not terminate or take adverse action against an employee because of the mismatch.
Adverse action is broader than firing. Cutting hours, moving someone off a schedule, suspending them, withholding a start date, delaying a promotion or telling them to stay home until it is sorted all qualify. Employers do these things believing they are being cautious, and in doing so create a claim where none existed.
The employee keeps working on normal terms while the case is pending. That is the rule.
What else not to do
Do not ask for specific documents to clear the mismatch. Do not demand immigration paperwork the employee did not choose to present. Do not run E-Verify on an applicant before hire, or selectively on employees who seem foreign. Each of those is a separate problem under the anti discrimination rules, independent of whether the mismatch was ever resolved.
Document the process
Keep the notices, the dates, the acknowledgement of private notification, and the employee decision. If this is ever examined, the question will be whether you followed the process, and the answer will be whatever your file shows.
Talk to us
If you have a mismatch in hand and are unsure what you may do with the employee in the meantime, the answer is usually nothing, and that is worth confirming before you act. We have practiced U.S. immigration law exclusively for over 30 years. Call the firm and we will tell you plainly whether you have a case and what it will take.
Further reading: what E-Verify is and is not, the employer exposure.