E-Verify Immigration Verification Program: An Employer’s Guide

Last updated:  

June 3, 2026
Glen D. Wasserstein, Managing Partner of ILG, specializes in immigration law, focusing on E-2 Investor Visas, L-1 visas, H-1B visas, and federal litigation. With a background in international relations, he founded ILG in 1996 and has addressed human trafficking at the United Nations Convention on Crime.

Table of Contents

The E-Verify immigration verification program is one of the most important tools U.S. employers have for confirming that new hires are legally allowed to work. It is fast, government-administered, and for a growing number of businesses, it is legally required.

This guide walks you through how the program works, who has to use it, what the law requires, and how to handle the situations that most commonly go wrong. If you are setting up E-Verify for the first time or reviewing your existing process, this is where to start.

What the Employment Eligibility Verification System Actually Does

E-Verify is an internet-based system run by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) in partnership with the Social Security Administration (SSA). When a new employee is hired, the employer enters their information from Form I-9 into the system. E-Verify checks those details against federal records and returns a result, usually within seconds.

The system confirms whether the identity and work authorization documents a new hire presents are consistent with what the government has on file. That is the extent of what it does. It does not determine a person’s overall immigration status, and it is not a background check.

A few things the program is specifically not designed for:

•       Screening applicants before a job offer is made

•       Checking the status of current employees without a specific legal reason

•       Re-verifying employees when their work authorization documents expire, unless required by law

How the Program Started

E-Verify began as the Basic Pilot Program under the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996. Participation was voluntary and limited to a small group of employers in a federal pilot.

Two developments changed its reach significantly. The Federal Acquisition Regulation extended the requirement to federal contractors. And over the following years, individual states began passing their own laws requiring private employers in certain situations to enroll. Today the program is used by millions of employers and processes hundreds of thousands of cases every year.

Laws That Require Employers to Use E-Verify

Participation in the E-Verify immigration verification program is not always a choice. Several categories of employers are legally required to enroll and use the system for every new hire.

Federal Contractors

Under the Federal Acquisition Regulation E-Verify clause (FAR 22.1803), businesses with federal contracts of $150,000 or more and a performance period of at least 120 days must use E-Verify for all new hires and for existing staff working on covered contracts. This requirement often flows down to subcontractors as well, so it is worth reviewing the terms of any federal contract carefully.

If this raises employment visa questions for your workforce, our immigration attorneys can help you navigate both the hiring and verification requirements together.

State Laws

More than 20 states have enacted legislation requiring some or all private employers to participate in E-Verify. The rules vary considerably. Some states require enrollment only when entering a government contract. Others apply the requirement to all private employers above a certain size. 

States with broad requirements include Arizona, Georgia, North Carolina, and Mississippi, among others. Because these laws are updated regularly, it is worth confirming the rules for every state where your business hires.

Federal and Public Employers

All federal agencies are required to use E-Verify for new hires. Many state agencies and local government bodies have adopted the same requirement, either by law or internal policy.

Voluntary Participation

Employers who are not legally required to participate can still enroll. Doing so voluntarily can provide some protection during immigration enforcement actions and demonstrates a good-faith approach to employment compliance.

Why Employers Use E-Verify

For those subject to the requirement, using E-Verify is non-negotiable. For those who are not, there are still practical reasons to consider it.

•       Results come back within seconds, so the process adds almost no time to onboarding.

•       Accurate employment eligibility verification reduces the risk of unknowingly hiring someone who is not authorized to work.

•       DHS and ICE generally treat good-faith participation as a mitigating factor during audits and investigations.

•       The process creates a documented compliance record that can be valuable during government inspections.

How to Use the E-Verify System

Once you know the program applies to your business, the process itself is straightforward. Here is how it works step by step.

Step 1: Enroll

Before creating any cases, employers must enroll through the official E-Verify website and sign a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with DHS. The MOU sets out the rules of the program, including obligations around privacy, record-keeping, and non-discrimination. Keep a copy on file.

Step 2: Post the Required Notices

Enrolled employers must display the E-Verify participation poster and the Right to Work poster in locations visible to both applicants and employees. Both are available through the E-Verify website.

Step 3: Complete Form I-9 First

The Form I-9 and E-Verify work alongside each other — one does not replace the other. The employee must complete their section of the I-9 on or before their first day. The employer must complete their section within three business days of the start date. The E-Verify case is then created after the I-9 is finished. Creating a case before the I-9 is complete is a procedural violation.

Step 4: Submit the Case

Enter the employee’s information from Form I-9 into the system exactly as it appears on the form. The E-Verify immigration verification program then compares that data against SSA and DHS records and returns a result.

Managing Multiple Locations

Employers with more than one site can designate an E-Verify Corporate Administrator to manage enrollment, add users, and oversee compliance across all locations centrally.

Common Misuses to Avoid

The rules around misuse are just as important as the rules about correct use. Violations can result in program termination, government investigation, or discrimination claims.

•       Do not run E-Verify on an applicant before they have accepted a job offer.

•       Do not select which employees to verify based on their name, appearance, national origin, or language.

•       Do not use the system to re-verify employees whose work authorization is expiring, unless you have a specific legal basis to do so.

•       Do not delay creating a case beyond the required timeframe after the I-9 is completed.

⚠  Important: Pre-screening is prohibited
Running E-Verify before a job offer is accepted, or selecting which candidates to check based on how they look or where they are from, is a violation of program rules and federal anti-discrimination law. Apply the same process to every new hire, every time.

What the Results Mean

After submitting a case, the system returns one of four outcomes:

•       Employment Authorized — The information matches government records. The employee is confirmed as eligible to work. No further action is needed.

•       Tentative Nonconfirmation (TNC) — There is a mismatch between the information submitted and government records. This is not a final decision and does not mean the employee is unauthorized.

•       Final Nonconfirmation — The discrepancy was not resolved after the employee had the opportunity to contact the relevant agency. The employer may terminate employment at this point.

•       Employer Data Entry Error — The case cannot be processed due to an input mistake. Correct the information and resubmit.

Photo Matching

For certain documents like U.S. Passports, Permanent Resident Cards, and Employment Authorization Documents, the system displays the photo from its own records alongside the document the employee presented. The employer confirms whether the photos match. This step is a fraud prevention measure and should be taken seriously.

How to Handle a Tentative Nonconfirmation

A tentative nonconfirmation result is not a finding that the employee is unauthorized. Mismatches happen regularly for reasons that have nothing to do with whether someone has the right to work.

Why Mismatches Happen

•       A name change after marriage or divorce that has not yet been updated in government records

•       A typographical error made by the employer when entering information

•       Government records that have not been updated following a citizenship or immigration status change

•       Incorrect document information recorded on Form I-9

What to Do When a TNC Occurs

1.     Notify the employee promptly and privately.

2.     Give them the printed Further Action Notice that E-Verify generates automatically.

3.     Let the employee decide whether they want to contest the result.

4.     If they do contest, allow them reasonable time to contact SSA or DHS. Employees have eight federal working days to initiate that process.

5.     Continue to employ and pay the employee while the matter is being resolved.

✖  Do not take adverse action based on a TNC
Terminating, suspending, or reducing pay for an employee solely because of a TNC result is a violation of E-Verify rules and may constitute unlawful employment discrimination. Wait for a Final Nonconfirmation before making any employment decision.

Limitations Worth Knowing

E-Verify is widely used, but it is not error-free. Advocacy organizations including the American Civil Liberties Union have raised concerns about database inaccuracies that can create problems for workers who are fully authorized. Some industries, particularly agriculture, have argued that mandatory enrollment adds costs without proportionate benefit.

These are real considerations. They are not a reason to avoid the program where it is required, but they are a reason to handle TNCs carefully and ensure every employee has a genuine opportunity to resolve a mismatch.

How ILG Can Help

E-Verify questions often surface alongside broader workforce immigration needs. If you are sponsoring a new hire who requires an employment visa, navigating a family visa for a relocating employee, or supporting someone on an individual immigration pathway, our team can handle both sides of the equation.

→ Speak With an Immigration Attorney

Frequently Asked Questions

Is E-Verify mandatory for all U.S. employers?

No. Most private employers participate voluntarily. That said, federal contractors, certain state contractors, and employers in states with mandatory E-Verify laws are required to enroll. Because the rules vary significantly by state and are updated regularly, it is worth checking the requirements for every state where you hire.

What happens if my business is required to use E-Verify but does not?

Failure to comply can result in loss of federal or state contracts, civil penalties, and heightened scrutiny from immigration enforcement agencies. The consequences depend on the applicable federal or state rule, but non-compliance is generally treated seriously.

Can I let someone go because of a Tentative Nonconfirmation result?

No. A TNC is not a final determination. Taking any adverse employment action — including termination, suspension, or pay reduction — solely on the basis of a TNC is a violation of E-Verify rules and may amount to unlawful employment discrimination. You must give the employee the opportunity to resolve the discrepancy first.

Does using E-Verify mean I do not need to complete Form I-9?

No. Form I-9 is a separate legal requirement under the Immigration Reform and Control Act. E-Verify works alongside the I-9 process and does not replace it. Every new hire must complete Form I-9 regardless of whether you use E-Verify.

Can an employee refuse to go through E-Verify?

If an employer is legally required to use E-Verify, participation is not optional for employees hired by that employer. However, an employee who receives a TNC result has the right to contest it and must be given the opportunity to do so. An employer cannot pressure an employee into waiving that right.

Conclusion

The E-Verify immigration verification program gives employers a reliable, fast way to confirm that new hires are authorized to work in the United States. For many businesses it is now a legal obligation. For others, it is a practical safeguard worth adopting voluntarily.

Getting the process right, from enrollment through to handling mismatches, protects both the business and the employee. If you are uncertain whether the program applies to you, or how to manage a specific situation under it, speaking with an immigration attorney is the most reliable next step.

→ Contact ILG for Immigration Guidance

Disclaimer

This content is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. You should not rely on this material as a substitute for specific legal counsel regarding your particular circumstances. If you have questions about E-Verify compliance or any other immigration matter, we recommend consulting a qualified immigration attorney.