An L-1B lets a company move an employee who has specialized knowledge of the company from an office abroad to a related office in the United States. It is temporary. A green card is permanent residence. One does not turn into the other. A green card is a separate case on separate rules, and for most routes the employer has to file it.
That matters because the L-1B has a hard stop at five years and cannot be extended past it. So the question is never only which green card route is best. It is which route can get far enough before the L-1B runs out. This page explains the routes from the beginning, then goes into the parts that decide these cases.
A few terms first
Green card means lawful permanent residence: the right to live and work in the United States without a status that expires.
Immigrant petition (Form I-140) is the filing that places you in a green card category. In most categories the employer files it.
Adjustment of status (Form I-485) is the application for the green card itself, made from inside the United States.
Labor certification, often called PERM, is a Department of Labor process in which the employer tests the United States labor market before it can sponsor a foreign employee. Most employment based green cards require it.
Priority date is your place in line. Green cards in each category are limited each year, and limited again by country, generally your country of birth. The State Department publishes a monthly Visa Bulletin showing whose turn has come.
You are allowed to pursue a green card while on an L-1
People worry that starting a green card case puts the L-1 at risk. It does not. 8 CFR 214.2(l)(16) says an employee may legitimately come to the United States for a temporary period as an L-1 nonimmigrant and, at the same time, lawfully seek to become a permanent resident of the United States
. It goes on to say that filing a labor certification, an immigrant petition or an adjustment application shall not be the basis for denying
an L-1 petition, an L-1 extension, or admission in L-1 status.
The clock you are working against
8 CFR 214.2(l)(15)(ii) sets it: The total period of stay may not exceed five years for aliens employed in a specialized knowledge capacity
, and No further extensions may be granted
.
Three things about that limit are not obvious.
A pending green card case does not extend it. The H-1B has rules that let an employee stay past the normal limit once a green card case has reached a certain stage. The L-1B has nothing like them. A labor certification filed in year four does not add a day to an L-1B.
Time in H-1B counts too. The limit in 8 CFR 214.2(l)(12)(i) applies to time spent under section 101(a)(15) (L) and/or (H) of the Act
. Years spent in H-1B before the L-1B come off the five.
A year abroad resets it. The same paragraph lifts the bar once the employee has resided and been physically present outside the United States, except for brief visits for business or pleasure, for the immediate prior year
.
The routes, one at a time
EB-1C, for multinational managers and executives
This category was built for companies that operate in more than one country. Its advantage is stated at 8 CFR 204.5(j)(5): No labor certification is required for this classification
. That removes the slowest step in most employment cases.
A common belief is that EB-1C is for L-1A employees and closed to L-1B employees. The regulation does not say that. EB-1C does not require L-1A status, or L status of any kind. It is a separate category with its own test, and an L-1B employee who meets the test can be sponsored without ever holding an L-1A.
The test, from 8 CFR 204.5(j)(3)(i) and (j)(5), has four parts:
- For someone already working here, that in the three years before entering as a nonimmigrant
the alien was employed by the entity abroad for at least one year in a managerial or executive capacity
. - That the job offered in the United States is managerial or executive.
- That the United States employer
is the same employer or a subsidiary or affiliate
of the company the employee worked for abroad. - That the United States employer
has been doing business for at least one year
.
For an L-1B employee, the first part is the one that decides it. An L-1 petition can rest on a year abroad in a position that was managerial, executive, or involved specialized knowledge
under 8 CFR 214.2(l)(3)(iv). EB-1C drops the third option. The year abroad has to have been managerial or executive.
So two L-1B employees doing the same job here can get opposite answers.
- Managed abroad, transferred on an L-1B. The role here was technical at first, or L-1B was chosen because it looked like the simpler filing. If that employee now holds a managerial or executive role here, EB-1C is open.
- Specialist abroad, promoted to manager here. The promotion may support a change to L-1A. It does not support EB-1C, because the year abroad was not managerial or executive.
Titles do not settle any of this. Duties do. Two rules in 8 CFR 204.5(j)(4) apply. First, A first-line supervisor is not considered to be acting in a managerial capacity merely by virtue of his or her supervisory duties unless the employees supervised are professional
. Second, head count alone is not the measure. Where staffing is considered, the reasonable needs of the organization, component, or function, in light of the overall purpose and stage of development
are taken into account.
Where the test is met and a visa number is available, the immigrant petition and the adjustment application can be filed together, which keeps the employee here and working after the L-1B ends. That strategy is set out in L-1B to L-1A: the six month rule. See also L-1 to EB-1C.
EB-2 or EB-3 through labor certification
This is the standard employer sponsored route, and the one most L-1B employees take. In outline: the employer obtains a prevailing wage determination from the Department of Labor, advertises the job and considers any United States workers who apply, files the labor certification application, and once it is certified files the immigrant petition. The adjustment application follows when the priority date is current. See employment based green cards.
Three problems come up repeatedly in L-1B cases.
The job requirements cannot be built around the employee. The knowledge that qualifies someone for an L-1B is knowledge of one company’s products or processes. A labor certification asks a different question, which is what the job normally requires. 20 CFR 656.17(h)(1) says the requirements must be those normally required for the occupation
unless the employer documents that they arise from business necessity. An application that demands years of experience with the company’s own internal systems invites that challenge.
Experience gained with the same employer usually cannot be counted. Under 20 CFR 656.17(i)(3), an employer generally cannot require applicants to have experience the employee lacked when hired, unless the employee gained it in a position not substantially comparable to the position for which certification is being sought
. Corporate structure matters here. For this rule, employer means an entity with the same Federal Employer Identification Number (FEIN)
. A foreign parent, subsidiary or affiliate is normally a separate entity from the United States employer, so experience gained there before the transfer can generally be counted. A branch is the harder case, because a branch is the same legal entity as the company abroad. Establish which entity employed the person, and when, before the requirements are drafted.
The employer has to show it can pay the wage. 8 CFR 204.5(g)(2) requires proof of ability to pay the offered wage at the time the priority date is established and continuing until the beneficiary obtains lawful permanent residence
, shown through annual reports, federal tax returns, or audited financial statements
. Where the employer has 100 or more workers, a statement from a financial officer may be accepted instead. The test is applied to the United States employer, not to the group. A United States subsidiary that is funded by its parent and reports losses can have a real problem here even where the group is large and profitable. The same rule applies to EB-1C.
EB-2 national interest waiver
A self petition. There is no employer sponsor and no labor certification, and the case belongs to you rather than to your employer, so it survives a job change. It requires an advanced degree or exceptional ability. Under Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016), it also requires showing that the work has substantial merit and national importance, that you are well positioned to advance it, and that on balance it benefits the United States to waive the job offer requirement. Specialized knowledge employees in research driven roles are sometimes better placed for this than they expect. It waits in the same EB-2 line as any other EB-2 case. See EB-2 national interest waiver.
EB-1A, extraordinary ability
Also a self petition with no labor certification. The standard is very high. 8 CFR 204.5(h)(2) defines extraordinary ability as a level of expertise indicating that the individual is one of that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field of endeavor
. It is rarely the answer for a specialized knowledge employee, but it is worth testing where there is a real record of recognition in the field. See EB-1A.
The arithmetic that decides it
Each route is a series of steps, and each step has its own wait. For a labor certification case those are the prevailing wage determination, the recruitment, the Department of Labor’s decision, the immigrant petition, and then the wait for the priority date. For nationals of heavily backlogged countries, the last wait dominates everything else.
These times change every month. Do not plan from a figure someone gave you last year. Check current processing times and the current Visa Bulletin on the day you plan.
Then compare the total against the L-1B time you have left. If the green card case cannot reach a filed adjustment application before the five years ends, you need a bridge. There are four.
- Change to H-1B. The H-1B normally allows six years, and time already spent in L-1B counts against it: the limit in 8 CFR 214.2(h)(13)(iii)(A) covers time spent
under section 101(a)(15)(H) and/or (L) of the Act
. What the H-1B adds is a way past six years. Under 8 CFR 214.2(h)(13)(iii)(D), extensions of up to one year at a time are available onceat least 365 days have elapsed
since the labor certification or the immigrant petition was filed. Under paragraph (E), an employee with an approved immigrant petition who is held back only by the per country limit can be extended up to three years at a time. The H-1B is subject to the annual lottery unless the employer is exempt, registration is in March, and the status does not start until October, so this has to begin early. See the H-1B Lottery Hub. - Promotion to L-1A. This adds up to two years, for seven in total, but only where USCIS approved the change when it happened and the employee has held the managerial or executive role for at least six months. See the six month rule.
- EB-1C filed together with the adjustment application. Available where the EB-1C test above is met and a visa number is available.
- A year abroad. This resets the clock. The employee can keep working for the group from the office abroad while the green card case continues, and finish it through a United States consulate.
Where these cases go wrong
Starting in year four. Every option exists in year one. By year four the labor certification route usually cannot finish in time, and the bridges that need lead time, the H-1B above all, may already be out of reach.
The employee has been managing for years on a specialist petition. A promotion happened, nobody amended the L-1B, and now the EB-1C petition describes managerial duties going back two years. 8 CFR 214.2(l)(7)(i)(C) requires an amended petition to reflect a change in capacity of employment (i.e., from a specialized knowledge position to a managerial position)
. The green card petition puts that history in front of the same agency. Address it before filing rather than in answer to a question about it.
The company abroad has stopped operating. EB-1C is for multinational organizations, and 8 CFR 204.5(j)(2) defines multinational to mean that the entity, or its affiliate or subsidiary, conducts business in two or more countries, one of which is the United States
. A group that has closed everything outside the United States has a problem with that definition, and with the L-1 itself.
The United States business was sold. EB-1C requires the United States employer to be the same employer as the company the employee worked for abroad, or its subsidiary or affiliate. A sale to an unrelated buyer cuts that link. The employee may be doing the same job at the same desk, and the category is gone. Check any acquisition or spin off against a pending or planned green card case before it closes.
The United States entity is new. EB-1C requires that it has been doing business for at least one year. An employee sent over to open a new office cannot be sponsored in this category until that year has passed.
Travel while the adjustment application is pending. Leaving the United States normally abandons a pending adjustment application unless advance parole was granted first. L-1 holders have an exception. Under 8 CFR 245.2(a)(4)(ii)(C), travel by an applicant who is in lawful H-1 or L-1 status shall not be deemed an abandonment of the application
if the employee remains eligible for that status, is returning to resume employment with the same employer
, and holds a valid visa where one is required. Once the L-1B has expired the exception no longer applies, and advance parole is needed before any trip.
What we look at first
How much L-1B time has been used, counting any earlier H-1B time. What the employee did abroad, and whether it was managerial or executive. What the employee does now, as opposed to what the original petition described. How the companies are related today, and whether both are still operating. The country of birth. Those answers usually settle the route in one conversation.
Talk to us
If you are on an L-1B and nobody has mapped your route yet, that is the gap to close now rather than in year four. We have practiced U.S. immigration law exclusively for over 30 years. Call the firm and we will tell you plainly which routes are open and what each will take.
Further reading: L-1 visas, L-1B, L-1 to EB-1C, L-1 requirements.